jealousy list – 社区黑料 America's Education News Source Wed, 17 Dec 2025 20:18:59 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 /wp-content/uploads/2022/05/cropped-74_favicon-32x32.png jealousy list – 社区黑料 32 32 The Jealousy List: A Shout-Out to 19 Education Stories We Admired in 2025 /article/the-jealousy-list-2025/ Mon, 15 Dec 2025 11:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=1025050 The news came fast and furious in 2025, and it was easy to miss some of the amazing journalism our colleagues at other media outlets produced. So, per our annual tradition, the team at 社区黑料 has compiled a list of the most memorable and moving education coverage that we鈥檝e read elsewhere this year. Full disclosure: We borrowed this idea from ; we鈥檝e just put our own education-focused twist on it.

This year鈥檚 list of stories takes us to Chicago, where several public schools sit mostly empty due to under enrollment; to Baltimore, where students are navigating a complicated transit system to get to school, often causing them to miss their first period class; and to Austin, where tweens attend 鈥渃otillion鈥 classes that teach them how to fold a napkin, hold utensils and dance. They also tell the stories of a beloved child care worker detained by ICE, a teen who tragically fell in love with a chatbot and Black-owned barbershops that have made it their mission to get boys in their communities to fall in love with reading. And there鈥檚 more鈥

The selections come from large national publications, as well as local news and nonprofit newsrooms. Below, in no particular order, are 19 stories our team admired most this year. We hope you take the time to read (and share) these important stories written and produced by talented education journalists in newsrooms across the country.

By , Chalkbeat, and , ProPublica

(Akilah Townsend for ProPublica)

The need to close underenrolled schools has become an important storyline this year, but few areas are dealing with as many nearly-empty buildings as Chicago Public Schools. ProPublica鈥檚 Jennifer Smith Richards and Chalkbeat鈥檚 Mila Koumpilova completed an in-depth analysis of underutilized schools in the country鈥檚 fourth-largest district and found that three in 10 buildings sit half-empty. And many come with a steep per-student price tag 鈥 the highest being $93,000. Richards and Koumpilova carefully explained Chicago鈥檚 history of school closures and the tense fight between district officials, families and the teachers union about next steps. They tune into what matters most: How tiny schools 鈥 some with enrollments in the double digits 鈥 impact student opportunities and educational experience. Some students seem to thrive in a tight-knit community, but the overarching lack of resources causes challenges for everyone. 鈥淵ou try to have a homecoming, but there鈥檚 no football team,鈥 said a former principal of Hirsch High School, which has 100 students in a building that can fit 1,000. 鈥淭here鈥檚 nothing to come home to.鈥

Selected by Staff Writer
Lauren Wagner

 

By The 19th 

(Courtesy Stephanie Wishon/The 19th)

As immigration enforcement activities have escalated over the past year, the early care and education workforce has been on edge. Immigrants represent more than 20% of the child care workforce nationwide. Chabeli Carrazana’s story for The 19th about Nicolle Orozco Forero 鈥 an immigrant child care provider who takes care of children with disabilities and was taken into ICE custody with her family 鈥 sheds light on the immense impact her detention and eventual deportation had on her community. Carrazana traces Orozco Forero鈥檚 journey: from fleeing Colombia two years earlier with her husband and sons, to searching for answers to her son鈥檚 unexplained illness to working toward her dream of opening her own child care program. Carrazana also illustrates how Orozco Forero鈥檚 rare expertise in supporting children with disabilities filled a critical gap in a field already strained by staffing shortages and limited specialized care. This story stays with you, especially the deep ripple effect of Orozco Forero鈥檚 deportation on the families and community she served.

Selected by Senior Editor
Marisa Busch

Visuals by Eli Durst; Text by Dina Gachman, The New York Times

(Eli Durst)

In Austin, tweens are attending 鈥渃otillion鈥 classes where they learn how to fold a napkin, hold utensils and dance. These aren鈥檛 essential life skills but surreptitiously the founders of the Southwest Austin Cotillion hope to teach the kids social skills and build their confidence. The strict no-electronics policy ensures the kids embrace the awkwardness of it all. It鈥檚 inspiring to see these kids put on a brave face and give way to the odd social mores 鈥 at least for a few hours. The fly on the wall black-and-white photography and spare text of this article did an excellent job illustrating the story. Kudos to producers Jolie Ruben and Josephine Sedgwick for creating an interactive experience that feels like an old Life magazine article reinvented for the web. Here, the future of storytelling borrows from the past and utilizes the latest technology where it works.

Selected by T74 Art & Technology Director
Eamonn Fitzmaurice

By Iowa Public Radio

(Lucius Pham/Iowa Public Radio)

Following the pandemic, school districts ramped up the use of the four-day school week to address a teacher absenteeism crisis and recruit staff at a time of severe shortages. Nicole Grundmeier with Iowa Public Radio鈥檚 Midwest Newsroom took a deep look at the trend with her August feature on how the policies have affected students. With data, research and personal stories, she captured the tough choices districts face as they weigh the benefits and drawbacks of giving staff and kids a longer weekend. Jayce Moody, who used to wander out of class and throw things in frustration, could better manage his behavior with a shorter school week. 鈥淗e no longer has to miss school for therapy and other appointments,鈥 she wrote. 鈥淛ayce jumped several levels in reading.鈥 But other families, she wrote, depend on schools for child care or food pantries to stretch meals until Monday. Grundmeier鈥檚 reporting offered a thoughtful examination of what happens before and after school boards vote on such a pivotal change to the schedule and how opting in favor of a reduced school week might not accomplish what they鈥檇 hoped it would. 

Selected by Senior Writer
Linda Jacobson

By and , The Baltimore Banner

(Kaitlin Newman/The Baltimore Banner)

Every day, hundreds of Baltimore middle and high schoolers are missing when the first-period bell rings 鈥 the result of a public transit system that makes it virtually impossible for as many as 25,000 students to get to class on time. Without a yellow bus system beyond elementary school, an investigation by The Baltimore Banner found, children as young as 11 crisscross the city on long, unpredictable and sometimes dangerous journeys that frequently get them to class late, or not at all. They stand in drenching rain, endure sexual harassment from strangers and witness violent fights on buses on commutes that can take 40 minutes each way on a good day 鈥 and often last twice as long. As the district doesn鈥檛 collect data on how students get to school, The Banner modeled their trips based on where they live and the school they attend. It then tracked the location of every Maryland Transit Administration bus every five seconds, 20 hours a day, and mapped those commutes using innovative, interactive graphics. The result: a poignant portrait of young people whose futures are being put at risk by the simple lack of a safe, dependable ride to school.

Selected by Executive Editor
Bev Weintraub

By , The Associated Press

(AP Photo/Brynn Anderson)

Housing insecurity can be incredibly disruptive to a family鈥檚 life, especially when it comes to children鈥檚 education. To highlight this challenge, Associated Press reporter Bianca V谩zquez Toness followed an Atlanta mother as she navigated the process of finding an apartment in the right school district, keeping her son on track academically and making enough money to keep the family afloat. There’s something about how Toness opened this story that felt brilliantly relatable and illustrated how issues, like housing insecurity, can happen to anyone. Toness does a good job humanizing these vulnerable circumstances and giving a glimpse into how hard parents work and fight to make sure their children are set up for success. You can tell Toness not only earned the trust of the family she highlighted, and told their story with the utmost amount of dignity, but she also was incredibly well-informed and resourced on how complex eviction is and can be. 

Selected by Staff Reporter
Jessika Harkay

By, The New York Times Magazine

(Naila Ruechel for The New York Times)

Florida attorney and mother of three, Megan Garcia, has become perhaps the best-known face in the fast-emerging legal and regulatory battle over AI chatbots. After her 14-year-old son died by suicide after forming an intensely romantic and sexually explicit relationship with a Character.AI bot, Garcia sued the tech creators for wrongful death, participated in multiple interviews and testified before the U.S. Senate about the need for stronger guardrails. By giving writer Jesse Baron access to her son鈥檚 conversations with the bot that personified Daenerys Targaryen from Game of Thrones, Garcia enabled a masterful Baron to produce a gripping and illuminating account of how a lonely and often-despairing young teen can fall in love with a robot, losing the line between reality and fantasy and slipping further away from the physical world and its human relationships. It鈥檚 a harrowing descent. The Garcia case will likely be among the first to establish legal precedent around the juggernaut that is AI. Days after Barron鈥檚 story ran, Character.AI announced that it was banning those under 18 from using its chatbots. All of that comes too late for Sewell Setzer III, who truly believed that by dying he would be going home to Westeros and his one true love.

Selected by Executive Editor
Kathy Moore 

By Alvin Chang, The Pudding 

(The Pudding)

How much do children鈥檚 environment and experiences influence the rest of their life? Alvin Chang鈥檚 interactive 鈥淭his Is a Teenager鈥 tackles that question with ease 鈥 turning National Longitudinal Surveys data into conversational, visual storytelling. The project follows hundreds of teens into their late 30s, allowing viewers to dive into 24 years of circumstances and consequences. As the interactive timeline moves through the years, you can see who went to college, who stayed financially stable, who was the victim of violence, who considers themselves happy. I was absorbed for hours. The project revisits one teen in particular, called Alex, who grew up in a high-risk environment. He had a difficult home life, was bullied and held back in school. By 2021, he reported feeling depressed 鈥渕ost of the time.鈥 Yet, as Chang writes, 鈥渨e are blamed for not going to college, for being unhealthy, for being poor, for not being able to afford healthcare and food and housing.鈥 That line hit hard, especially after watching Alex鈥檚 life unfold. The equally engaging complements the piece, making decades-long data feel digestible.

Selected by T74 Senior Producer
Meghan Gallagher

By  The Hechinger Report

(Seth Wenig/AP)

A report on Trump administration college admissions proposals, published earlier this month by The Hechinger Report鈥檚 Jon Marcus, may turn out to be one of the most consequential pieces of journalism of the year. 

Marcus looked at admissions data and found that while President Trump鈥檚 scrutiny largely zeroes in on race, his ban on DEI policies could harm men, notably white men, his most loyal demographic.

That鈥檚 because universities for decades have been quietly offering men, who tend to leave high school with fewer skills and lower GPAs, an advantage. While they鈥檝e historically enrolled more women than men, federal data show, they鈥檝e also admitted higher percentages of male applicants. At Baylor University, for instance, 56.8% of males who applied got in, versus. just 47.9% of females.

So while colleges may soon follow U.S. Education Secretary Linda McMahon鈥檚 exhortation to judge aspiring students 鈥渟olely on their merits, not their race or sex,鈥 the end result could be thousands of young men who don鈥檛 have a place in future freshman classes 鈥 a development that 鈥渄rips with irony,鈥 says one top policy wonk.

Selected by Senior Writer
Greg Toppo

By , The Philadelphia Inquirer

(Jessica Griffin/The Philadelphia Inquirer)

Anyone who’s spent much time reading about schools will remember New York City’s “rubber room” 鈥 an archipelago of reassignment centers for hundreds of school employees awaiting arbitration for alleged professional offenses. In January, more than 15 years after journalist Steven Brill first popularized the term, Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Kristen Graham gave us an account of Philadelphia’s own rubber room, a way station where some teachers and administrators spend years gathering paychecks and dust. The dispatch offers excellent texture about wasted days in what is effectively a professional prison 鈥 the long-timers graduate into the best seats, while access to extension cords is carefully negotiated 鈥 but many of the details are dispiritingly familiar: Complaints from former rubber room occupants first bubbled into a citywide scandal back in 2011. It increasingly feels like the broader subject of teacher job protections and complaint adjudication is itself akin to the rubber room, a windowless abyss to which all education journalists must eternally return.   

Selected by Senior Writer
Kevin Mahnken

By , NBCU Academy

(NBCU Academy/YouTube)

Alvin Irby, a former first grade teacher, saw an opportunity to improve literacy among Black boys while watching one of his students get a haircut. In 2013, he founded Barbershop Books, providing books for children to read while sitting in the barber鈥檚 chair and training barbers to become mentors to their young clients. Reporter Maya Brown, who was then with NBCU Academy Multimedia, provides a beautiful masterclass in visual storytelling that shows how familiar cultural settings can be used to boost literacy and reading comprehension. In Brown鈥檚 video and text package, we see students getting haircuts and walking away with a stronger motivation to read and barbers who are passionate and committed reading coaches. What excited me most about this story was knowing that Black boys across the country are being seen and supported through Barbershop Books, which is now in 60 cities across the U.S. Brown brilliantly captures how these encounters not only shape the students鈥 hairline but their education journey, too. 

Selected by Digital Producer
Trinity Alicia

By and , ProPublica 

(Win McNamee/Getty)

What if the leaders put in charge of the nation鈥檚 public schools are actually rooting against them? ProPublica analyzed dozens of hours of audio and video footage of public and private speaking events 鈥 as well as writings 鈥 for Education Secretary Linda McMahon鈥檚 appointees finding 鈥渁 recurring theme is the desire to enable more families to leave public schools.鈥 and 鈥檚 story dug deep into these records to paint a vivid picture of the powerful forces that both govern and seek to dismantle public education. Every sentence was impactful and the graphics, while cartoonish and playful, powerfully illustrate each point. The voices that fill the piece were well chosen, each offering an insightful view, to a movement that started well before the current administration. For instance, Maurice T. Cunningham, a retired associate professor of political science at the University of Massachusetts provided helpful context, saying parents鈥 rights groups have long aimed 鈥渢o undermine teachers unions, protect their wealthy donors from having to contribute their fair share in taxes to strengthen public schools, and provide profit opportunities through school privatization.鈥 

Selected by Senior Reporter
Jo Napolitano

By , The Hechinger Report

(Patience Zalanga for The Hechinger Report)

In 2006, Minnesota passed a law requiring all eighth graders to take Algebra I, a move designed to boost the number of students taking calculus and eventually going into math and science careers. But an investigation by The Hechinger Report suggests it hasn鈥檛 worked as planned. Reporter Steven Yoder analyzed federal data from 2009 to 2017 and found the share of the state鈥檚 students taking calculus rose modestly, from 1.25% to 1.76%. But other states saw far larger gains, and Minnesota dropped from sixth to 10th place among states for calculus enrollment as a share of total enrollment. The state鈥檚 ranking for eighth grade math scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress also fell. Yoder鈥檚 research, including visits to classrooms in one Minnesota school district, demonstrates the need for more nuance in determining who should take algebra and when.  

Selected by Contributing Editor
Phyllis Jordan

By , The Washington Post

(Jay Pickthorn/For The Washington Post)

You would know this compulsively readable feature was written by The Washington Post’s Casey Parks even without the byline. Parks is a master at coming to inhabit a small community, chameleon-like, and finding its social glue. In this case, it鈥檚 the lone bookstore in Vermillion, South Dakota, threatened with closure when the state legislature voted to force the 10-year-old daughter of its owners to use the boys’ bathroom at school. Five and a half years ago, Mike and Jen Phelan opened the store on Vermillion鈥檚 Main Street where, red state reputation notwithstanding, most of the brick storefronts sported Pride flags. The locals embraced the couple鈥檚 transgender daughter, with the Vermillion School Board voting in 2021 to allow her to use the girls鈥 bathroom. Which she did without incident until South Dakota鈥檚 GOP statehouse majority passed a bathroom ban this year. As the Phelans packed to move to a New England community where the girl would be affirmed, they prepared to sell the business to Nova and Elias Donstad, a trans couple. 鈥淭hey fell in love reading next to each other most evenings, and they fell for South Dakota the way many transplants did 鈥 accidentally,鈥 writes Parks. The bookworms were desperate to rescue the store, but couldn鈥檛 afford to buy it. As it happens, their neighbors couldn鈥檛 imagine Vermillion without the shop, and raised $22,000 for the couple鈥檚 down payment. 

Selected by Senior Writer & National Correspondent
Beth Hawkins

By , CalMatters

(Shelby Knowles for CalMatters)

Since The Boston Globe鈥檚 early 2000s reporting exposed widespread childhood sexual abuse in the Catholic church, similar school-based stories have proliferated. This has been made possible as states open 鈥渓ook-back鈥 windows, temporarily lifting the statute of limitations on civil abuse cases. Survivors of childhood sexual abuse I鈥檝e spoken with for my own reporting have shared the power of these windows: they provide an opportunity 鈥 albeit delayed 鈥 for justice. CalMatters Carolyn Jones鈥 reporting on California鈥檚 2020 law 鈥 which provided a three-year window for victims to file claims and made it easier to sue school districts and counties 鈥 stands out because of her ability to skillfully and thoughtfully walk a tough line: emphasizing the very real presence of sexual abuse in schools and the need to hold complicit institutions accountable, while also exposing the unintended financial consequences that can result from these windows. The story raises complex and thorny questions: Who should be held accountable for years-old sexual abuse, especially in cases where the perpetrator is dead and school district personnel have since turned over? And how can we hold the systems that failed these victims responsible, without pulling funding from current students? 

Selected by Staff Reporter
Amanda Geduld

By , NPR

(Melissa Ann Pinney)

NPR鈥檚 November interview with photographer Melissa Ann Pinney included a trove of incredible pictures that practically jump off the page, err screen. After being granted access to two Chicago schools starting seven years ago, Pinney began taking photos in her 鈥淏ecoming Themselves鈥 series. Pinney captures incredible facial expressions and body language of what she called 鈥渙ften overlooked communities of children and teens in Chicago.鈥 Her ability to play with light and shadows adds a dimension of moodiness that feels right when teens are the subject. Each picture tells its own story with a range of emotions and experiences, including hope, fear, friendship, and love. My favorites include Lizzie Williams in her My Little Pony leggings;  Kho鈥檝ya Greenwood and her brother Coby at a prom celebration; and Jo Gonda and Andrew McDermott at the prom. Each photo is truly a gem 鈥 and Pinney鈥檚 interview adds to the experience.  

Selected by Executive Editor
JoAnne Wasserman

By Photographs by , The New York Times 

(Lucy Lu, The New York Times)

This year鈥檚 50th anniversary of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act offers a stark reminder that we鈥檙e not that far removed from the days when people with intellectual and developmental disabilities were sent away to special public institutions. One of those, the Walter E. Fernald State School in Waltham, Massachusetts 鈥 鈥渢he Fernald,鈥 as locals call it 鈥 housed John Scott, who had spina bifida and spent most of his 17 years there before his death and burial in an unmarked grave in 1973. In this heartbreaking and masterfully told story, New York Times reporter Sonia Rao describes the journey of Scott鈥檚 brother David, who was just 7 when John died, as he seeks to learn more about his brother and what happened to him. A direct appeal to the governor eventually led him to a rust-colored accordion folder filled with 70 documents about his brother鈥檚 short life. In interviews, a teacher described John as one of her brightest students and 鈥渁 little ray of sunshine.鈥 But she also spoke of what David called 鈥渁trocities鈥 at the school. 鈥淓ighty percent of the stuff I saw there, I wish I could erase from my mind,鈥 she said. That reality is especially poignant given that there were at least 10,000 unmarked graves for people like John in Massachusetts alone 鈥 and the Fernald is one of hundreds of similar institutions for people with disabilities that once dotted the national landscape.

Selected by Executive Editor
Andrew Brownstein

By , Voice of San Diego

(Vito di Stefano for Voice of San Diego)

Just when you thought you鈥檇 seen every kind of shady behavior around AI and digital learning, along comes Voice of San Diego鈥檚 Jakob McWhinney with an: Would you believe that fraudsters are stealing community college students鈥 identities and enrolling in remote classes to cash in on their financial aid? McWhinney finds that thieves create 鈥渂ot students鈥 that enroll in large online classes and remain just long enough to cash in on state and federal aid. They often turn to generative AI to fake the first few assignments. McWhinney finds that one in four California community college applicants last year was a suspected bot. He offers an to help readers understand exactly how it all works. If the aid theft isn鈥檛 bad enough, he finds that the bots also bump real students from classes 鈥 and wreak havoc around enrollment. He talks to a Southwestern College professor who realizes that, two weeks into last spring鈥檚 semester, just 15 of the 104 students enrolled in her classes and a wait-list, were real. As a result, Southwestern now requires all remote students to show up face-to-face at enrollment time just to prove they鈥檙e real. 

Selected by Senior Writer
Greg Toppo

By , NBC News

(Vail School District)

In a year that will be remembered for intensifying political extremism on the internet and a sharp increase in political violence in the physical world, investigative reporter Tyler Kingkade of NBC News surfaces a compelling tale of what happens when everyday people find themselves in the crosshairs of the culture wars. After Charlie Kirk鈥檚 murder led to government-endorsed revenge against the far-right pundit鈥檚 critics, Kingkade highlighted how a small school district in Arizona was thrust into a campus safety crisis after an online disinformation campaign falsely accused teachers of celebrating his death. The lie, which centered on a costume worn by math teachers, was perpetuated by conservative influencers and Republican lawmakers. The resulting firestorm offers clear evidence that online vitriol can destabilize public safety 鈥 including in schools.

Selected by Investigative Reporter
Mark Keierleber
]]>
The Jealousy List: 16 Education Articles We Wish We Had Written in 2024 /article/the-jealousy-list-16-education-articles-we-wish-we-had-written-in-2024/ Tue, 10 Dec 2024 12:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=735844 As 2024 draws to a close, the team at 社区黑料 embarked on our annual tradition of compiling education stories we wished we had published over the last year. We borrowed this idea from Bloomberg Businessweek鈥檚 Jealousy List 鈥 the publication鈥檚 annual tribute to the most important stories of the year by their colleagues at other media outlets. (You can read their latest )

At 社区黑料, we鈥檙e celebrating the most memorable coverage about schools and students that we鈥檝e read. Our picks include stories on a range of education topics, from teacher shortages and learning recovery to a notable tribute to a crossing guard who left an indelible impression on the students he guided safely to school each day.

Below, in no particular order, are 16 of the articles we felt were the most impactful in 2024. We hope you take the time to read (and share) these important stories written by talented journalists from across the country.

By , CT Mirror

We know the shocking truth: The U.S. adult illiteracy rate is high, with 21%, or 43 million adults, unable to understand basic vocabulary, compare and contrast information and paraphrase what鈥檚 been read.

Jessika Harkay鈥檚 Connecticut Mirror story is a carefully executed autopsy of how one young woman became part of that statistic. This story is a standout to me because it documents how a student like Aleysha Ortiz could be pushed through school and graduate 鈥 even though she is barely literate. I like its tight structure and details, such as how she had to go to 鈥渟chool two times in one day,鈥 recording what the teacher said during class; and then going home and listening to the recording again. The cost was high and heartbreaking: 鈥淭o this day I鈥檝e never been out to a movie theatre with friends, ever,鈥 Ortiz reveals. 鈥淚 didn鈥檛 have time to have fun.鈥 .

Selected by T74 Executive Editor, JoAnne Wasserman

By  & , ProPublica

Known as a model for school choice nationally, Arizona’s voucher program is a case study ripe for investigation. ProPublica reporters Eli Hager and Lucas Waldron dug into Maricopa County鈥檚 data, finding the vast majority of families attending private schools using public funds were from more affluent ZIP codes. This is despite conservatives touting the program as transformational for all. 

Ash Ponders, special to ProPublica

Like many inequities in education, ProPublica鈥檚 probe led reporters to housing segregation. Private schools, typically located in wealthier areas, remain out of reach geographically, with some facing two-hour city bus routes or $30 cab rides each way. While the reporting in this story is data-driven, the storytelling stays rooted in empathy for the daily lives and concerns of three families who were eager to use the state鈥檚 voucher system to pursue a better education for their children, but ultimately gave up on the idea. Instead, the article points out, many parents are coming together to make their own public schools better. Read the full story .

Selected by T74 Staff Reporter Marianna McMurdock

By , Block Club Chicago

School staffing crisis stories were abundant this year, but Block Club Chicago鈥檚 investigative reporter Mina Bloom humanized the consequences of teacher shortages, centering the story on one brave student who took control of her class鈥檚 education after the teacher鈥檚 long absence. A model of how local stories can bring awareness to national issues, Bloom skillfully weaved in meticulous data and the history of the school. 

Clemente student Carolina Carchi taught her alegbra and chemistry classes in the absence of permanent teachers. (Carolina Carchi)

After a year of headlines decrying the 鈥渄isengaged student,鈥 it was heartening to read about students so committed and passionate about learning that they refused to let the school鈥檚 shortcomings disrupt their education. I will be thinking often about Carolina Carchi, the 15-year-old who taught her classmates about the properties of liquids and solids and how to balance chemical equations. It鈥檚 crucial to celebrate young people like Carolina and amplify their voices to hold systems accountable. .

Selected by T74 Senior Producer Meghan Gallagher

By  and , The New York Times

When I was in grade school in the Midwest we regularly practiced tornado drills, filing down to the basement to duck and cover. Today, the kids are trained to barricade themselves in the classroom to protect against a different nemesis: school shooters. With common-sense solutions to school shootings seemingly stalled, worried parents are taking matters into their own hands to protect their kids at whatever cost.

An image from a demonstration on the website of Tuffy Packs, a company that manufactures ballistic shield inserts for backpacks. (The New York Times)

This New York Times story by Emily Baumgaertner and Alex Kalman is an eye-opening expose of the solutions and products that parents and school districts are being sold to protect their children. At one education trade show, the reporters saw vendors offering a wide range of bulletproof school items, from pencil pouches, clipboards and three-ring binders to hoodies, desks and whiteboards. Bulletproof backpack inserts were also being marketed with the help of an animated turtle named Tank who struggles to pronounce and encourages the kids to crouch behind their backpack 鈥渟hells鈥 in a safe spot. As Baumgaertner and Kalman explain, the market is almost as absurd as the problem it seeks to resolve. .

Selected by T74 Art & Technology Director Eamonn Fitzmaurice

By , OregonLive

For decades, boys have been shrinking as a percentage of American college students. As Sami Edge reported for The Oregonian and its website OregonLive this summer, the gender gap is especially prominent in rural areas, where even high-achieving males are unlikely to proceed immediately to college after finishing high school. As part of a wide-ranging, , the reporter followed several seniors in comparatively remote districts across Central and Eastern Oregon, artfully uncovering their reasons for holding pat rather than signing up for more years of schooling.

Shawn Whinery, left, and Wesley Ince relax at the Ince family home after their last day of school in Ontario. ()

Some of the boys Edge encounters say they and their friends feel financially pressured to defer their plans for college, citing either the high cost of tuition or the need to assume responsibility at family farms. But others 鈥 including the main subjects of her story, a high school valedictorian and his close friend 鈥 simply seem adrift. Maybe they鈥檒l enroll in an apprenticeship, or else take a job at a gas station; maybe they鈥檒l study music, or move East to live with a long-distance romantic partner. Readers will finish the piece with a better understanding of social trends in parts of Oregon that might otherwise be overlooked, but they also gain a sense of the generational ambivalence toward higher education that has taken hold far beyond the Pacific Northwest. .

Selected by T74 Senior Reporter Kevin Mahnken

By  & , The Hechinger Report

Fazil Khan and Sarah Butrymowicz鈥檚 story about the nebulous nature of school suspensions in several states shines a light on a critical form of chronic inequity in American schools. The story notes the uneven application of such harsh discipline and how some administrators, recognizing that students of color are too often targeted, are desperate for better alternatives. 

Camilla Forte/The Hechinger Report

The Hechinger Report鈥檚 deep data dive found 88% of suspensions in Texas in 2023 were marked as a 鈥渧iolation of student code of conduct鈥 with no additional detail. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 more than a million suspensions last school year alone,鈥 the authors note. In Mississippi, the similarly vague 鈥渘oncriminal behavior鈥 slot described hundreds of thousands of suspensions over a five-year period. Students in Indiana, Alabama and Vermont were cast out for equally vague reasons, the reporters found. All this can lead to some long-term consequences: Research has shown suspended students often suffer poor academic performance and higher dropout rates. Highlighting this important story is bittersweet as it marks a posthumous tribute for Khan, who died in a fire earlier this year. You can read.

Selected by T74 Senior Reporter Jo Napolitano

By  and , ProPublica

As a former charter and public school teacher, stories about private, for-profit schools always catch my skeptical eye. When I saw this piece from ProPublica homed in on one such school that serves particularly vulnerable students in a residential setting, I was intrigued. Shrub Oak International School, which opened in 2018 in Westchester County, New York, enrolls students with autism, including kids who have behavioral challenges and complex medical needs and who other schools have turned away. 

Shrub Oak serves students on the autism spectrum who might also have challenging behavioral and medical needs. (Liz Moughon/ProPublica)

Shrub Oak is one of the most expensive therapeutic boarding schools in America, with tuition as high as $316,400 per year, ProPublica found. Despite lacking any meaningful oversight from the state, the school still receives public money from districts across the country. Beyond the financial component, the lack of regulation has allowed the school to renege on promises to parents and has resulted in several alleged incidents of abuse and neglect. Pulling from court documents, interviews with nearly 30 families and dozens of workers, ProPublica鈥檚 Jennifer Smith Richards and Jodi S. Cohen present a compelling and gutting investigation about what happens when a school meant to protect and educate students in need falls through the cracks of regulatory oversight and fails the people who need its services most. .

Selected by T74 Staff Reporter, Amanda Geduld

By , Honolulu Civil Beat

School bus driver shortages remained in 2024, and education reporters did their part to cover the chaos. Stories described students waiting hours for buses that never came and districts recruiting lunchroom staff and office clerks to drive. But Megan Tagami of Hawaii鈥檚 Civil Beat broke down the reason why the state education department kept canceling and combining routes at the last minute 鈥 its heavy reliance on contracts with private bus companies instead of owning its own fleet and hiring its own drivers. One contractor, in particular, failed to notify the department that it would be unable to fulfill more than 100 of its routes until just weeks before the school year started. 

(Cory Lum/Civil Beat/2017)

Tagami showed how transportation costs in Hawaii have skyrocketed 鈥 in part because the state鈥檚 education department increased the size of its bus contracts to avoid these hassles and reimburses parents for driving their kids to school. The piece offered readers a valuable, local angle on a national problem that is disruptive for families and impacts learning time for students. .

Selected by T74 Senior Writer Linda Jacobson

By & , Associated Press

Smokin’ in the boys’ room is a thing of the past 鈥 and now it appears vaping is, too. In an article for The Associated Press, Jacqueline Munis and Ella McCarthy reveal the startling degree to which schools nationwide deploy “vape detection” surveillance tools to sniff out students’ electronic cigarette use in school bathrooms. Schools have spent millions of dollars on sensors designed to detect e-cigarette vapor and surveillance cameras that capture the students-turned-suspects on their way out of the facilities. Along with privacy concerns, the censors have led to harsh discipline for students, including in-school suspensions and even felony charges. .

Selected by T74 Investigative Reporter Mark Keierleber

By , The Lens

by Marta Jewson of the New Orleans nonprofit The Lens is a master class on the value of pushing beyond a news item鈥檚 top, four-alarm takeaway to probe for broader potential ramifications. Few other outlets so much as noticed that in September Louisiana joined 16 other states in suing the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, arguing that gender dysphoria 鈥 a medical diagnosis sometimes made when a person鈥檚 gender identity differs from the gender they were assigned at birth 鈥 should not be considered a disability.聽Jewson鈥檚 story not only reported that the lawsuit could dismantle portions of the Americans with Disabilities Act, which provides key protections to people in schools and in employment, housing, public services and many other spheres of society, but at a moment when much 鈥渃ulture war鈥 reporting focuses on adult politics, she made a point to include the voices of students who could be impacted by this lawsuit in multiple ways. Read .

Selected by T74 Senior Writer & National Correspondent Beth Hawkins

By , Vox

I鈥檓 drawn to stories that examine how historical movements have influenced current events and can challenge readers to learn from the past and apply it to what is happening now. In this story, Vox reporter Nicole Narea excels at this by shining a light on the parallels between today鈥檚 youth-led pro-Palestine protests on college campuses and student activism of the past, including the 1960s protests against the Vietnam War and the 1980s campus movements against apartheid in South Africa. 

The story is not just a mere timeline of student protest coverage. It describes why college campuses remain distinctive environments for fostering critical thinking, personal development and cultural awareness. Narea鈥檚 story blends history, politics, activism and the power of student voices to illustrate how college students have long been at the forefront of social change. 

(Mostafa Bassim/Anadolu via Getty Images)

The story also notes how swiftly today鈥檚 student movements can be met with police crackdowns, arrests and political pressure, even when they are predominantly peaceful in nature. It鈥檚  a thought-provoking piece that speaks to what today鈥檚 students encounter as they fight for their rights and those of others 鈥 often facing backlash and personal danger. .

Selected by T74 Staff Reporter, Trinity Alicia

By  & , New York Times

There鈥檚 been a good deal of reporting on the effects of the pandemic on older children. Less covered is the impact on the nation鈥檚 youngest children 鈥 those who were babies, toddlers and preschoolers during the height of the pandemic and who are now school-aged.

In this story, The New York Times鈥 Claire Cain Miller and Sarah Mervosh share findings from interviews with teachers, pediatricians and early childhood experts. The bottom line: Many of these younger children are showing signs of academic and developmental delays. There are also concerns related to a variety of areas, like speech and language development, emotional regulation, social interactions, behavior, attention span, core strength and fine motor skills. Researchers suggested that a number of factors affected young children during the pandemic, including parental stress, less exposure to people, more time on screens and lower preschool attendance.

Despite these trends, some experts said recovery is possible, pointing to resources that can help as well as evidence that the early years of brain development in young children positions them well to 鈥渃atch up.鈥 .

Selected by T74 Staff Reporter, Marisa Busch

By , The Boston Globe

The Boston Globe鈥檚 Mandy McLaren and Neena Hagen collected and reviewed more than 2,600 confidential agreements between Massachusetts school districts and families of students with special needs showing that families who can afford a lawyer are often able to negotiate six-figure placements at specialized schools, while those who can鈥檛 afford one watch their kids languish in neighborhood schools.

It鈥檚 an amazing investigative effort that lays bare what one mother calls the 鈥渢edious and maddening back-and-forth鈥 with a district. She negotiates a secret agreement for annual $40,000 tuition payments at a private school, but no one can know 鈥 especially not other parents 鈥渟till fumbling in the dark鈥 for ways to help their kids. The nondisclosure agreements weaken other families鈥 ability to find 鈥渇ree and appropriate鈥 settings for their kids, as federal law demands. One expert tells the Globe that such secrecy runs counter to the spirit of the law, which envisioned families being resources for each other. 鈥淭he way this is set up, it鈥檚 made to break you,鈥 says a father who doesn鈥檛 have the money to fight his kid鈥檚 district. .

Selected by T74 Senior Writer Greg Toppo

By , ProPublica

Enrollment drops. Funding cliff. School closures. These are the buzzwords and edu-cliches that often mask the complex realities behind one of the bigger school shifts in recent memory. In this collaboration between ProPublica and The New Yorker, reporter Alec MacGillis reverses the script, focusing on the effects of closing one school 鈥 Walter Cooper Academy, located in a mostly Black neighborhood of Rochester, New York 鈥 on one family. This close-up approach humanizes a sense of loss that often gets clouded by the abstractions. 鈥淭here is a pathos to a closed school that doesn鈥檛 apply to a shuttered courthouse or post office,鈥 he writes.

While not pulling punches on the disastrous effects of COVID school lockdowns, which sent many parents to charters or schools in the suburbs, MacGillis keeps his eye on the Black families who research shows are disproportionately affected by such closures. 鈥淓very time we think we鈥檙e doing something right for our kids,鈥 one parent says, 鈥渟omeone comes in and dictates to us that our choices are not valid.鈥

Selected by T74 Executive Editor, Andrew Brownstein

By , Houston Landing

When a Houston middle school made a remarkable turnaround in just one year, Houston Landing鈥檚 Asher Lehrer-Small wanted to know what was happening there. He spent two full days at Forest Brook Middle school, observing 16 classes, conducting two dozen interviews and joining staff meetings. 

What he found was a school that embraced the priorities of the district鈥檚 new superintendent, Michael Miles: stricter disciplinary practices, more rigorous instruction and increased emphasis on test scores. But he also found teachers taking the time to build relationships with students and to bring their own personalities into their lessons.

(Antranik Tavitian / Houston Landing)

鈥淟ast year, when we started this process, scholars went home tired,鈥 Principal Alicia Lewis told him. 鈥淭he parents call me. 鈥楳s. Lewis,鈥 they say, 鈥榠t鈥檚 too much work.鈥 It鈥檚 not. It鈥檚 not too much work. They need it. And look at what happened. They grew.鈥 The story by Lehrer-Small, a veteran of 社区黑料, demonstrates the power of getting out from behind the computer and experiencing what is actually happening in the classroom. .

Selected by T74 Executive Editor, Bev Weintraub, written by Phyllis Jordan

By , The New York Times

Many of the education stories we read have a big frame, focused on topics like science of reading that affect millions of students but are often abstract.

Richie Henderson at work. (Avenues of the World School)

Joe Sexton鈥檚 article for The New York Times highlights the importance of students鈥 human interactions at school. He focuses on crossing guard Richard Henderson, who greeted children by name at a New York City school and became a beloved member of the community. When he was shot to death on a subway, the school community came together to support his family, setting up memorials outside of the school and establishing a GoFundMe site that raised $378,000. The right policies are obviously crucial, but this article is a good reminder that schools are made up of people. And the best schools have really good people. .

Selected by T74 Director of Audience & Growth, Christian Skotte
]]>