The Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board voted unanimously against an application Monday for a virtual Jewish charter school, citing聽the state supreme court’s 2024 ruling that public funding for a religious school would violate state law.聽As expected, some board members voiced support for聽Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School Foundation.

“I think our hands are tied,” said Board Member Damon Gardenhire, who said he didn’t see much difference between Ben Gamla’s application and a now-closed Native American charter school that featured a “spiritual component.”聽

In a statement responding to the vote, Brett Farley, a member of the proposed school’s board, said organizers plan to challenge the decision in federal court. “Oklahoma families should have the freedom to choose schools that best meet their children’s needs 鈥� without losing strong options simply because they are faith-based,” he said.

The Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board is expected to deny an application for a Jewish charter school Monday, but will likely welcome organizers of the school to take them to court.

Peter Deutsch, founder of the Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School Foundation, and a former Democratic congressman, made his pitch for the school in January, saying that he aims to bring 鈥渁 rigorous, values-driven education鈥� to Jewish parents in Oklahoma.

鈥淚 anticipate that our board would like to grant them the application,鈥� Brian Shellem, the board chair, told 社区黑料. 鈥淏ut we can’t snub our nose at the court either.鈥�

He means the Oklahoma Supreme Court, which ruled against the nation鈥檚 first Catholic charter school in 2024. That decision still stands after the U.S. Supreme Court deadlocked over that case last year. The charter board鈥檚 likely denial of Ben Gamla鈥檚 application is expected to spark another lawsuit, pitting against those who say it would violate the Constitution’s prohibition on establishing a religion. With a case over a proposed Christian charter in Tennessee already in federal court and another religious school in Colorado founded to test the same legal question, there鈥檚 little doubt that the nation鈥檚 highest court will eventually settle the debate.

鈥淚t is hard for me to imagine the court doesn鈥檛 take the issue again when it comes to it,鈥� said Derek Black, a constitutional law professor at the University of South Carolina. But after Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused herself in the case over St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, resulting in the 4-4 tie, the justices likely in favor of religious charters, he said, 鈥渨ould want a case that was very strong.鈥�

鈥楶ray and hear Scripture鈥�

So far, the only case to watch is in Tennessee. Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville, a nonprofit that wants to open a K-8 Christian charter school, sued the Knox County school board because the district wouldn鈥檛 accept its letter of intent to apply. State law prohibits charter schools from being religious. 

鈥淪tudents will begin to develop biblical literacy in kindergarten and begin taking catechism lessons by third grade,鈥� according to Wilberforce Academy鈥檚 request for a quick ruling in the case. 鈥淎nd they will pray and hear Scripture together in a school assembly every morning.鈥�

As St. Isidore did before them, Wilberforce argues that the nonprofit is a 鈥減rivate actor鈥� and that approving its charter application would not turn it into a government entity.

The Knox County board told the court that it will 鈥渕ost likely鈥� not take a position on the legality of Wilberforce鈥檚 argument. On Thursday, the board rejected asking state education Commissioner Lizzette Reynolds to consider granting Wilberforce Academy a waiver so they can open the Christian school.

The Knox board, however, also said the issue of religious charter schools 鈥渄eserves a thorough examination by the federal courts.鈥� 

Judge Charles Atchley Jr, for the Eastern District of Tennessee, thinks so, too. Last week, he allowed a group of Knox County parents and religious leaders, who oppose Wilberforce鈥檚 application, . 

The case, he wrote, has the 鈥減otential to reshape First Amendment jurisprudence in the educational context鈥� and it wouldn鈥檛 serve the court or parties involved to not have 鈥渧igorous advocacy on both sides.鈥�

Amanda Collins, a retired Knox County school psychologist, is among those who have signed up to fight against Wilberforce Academy. She has two children still in the district and one who graduated in 2024. She grew concerned about Wilberforce Academy when she learned the organization didn鈥檛 have a history of operating charter schools in the state and feels its attorneys are using the district to 鈥渕erely force an issue up the ladder to the Supreme Court.鈥�

鈥淚n Tennessee, we have plenty of things that are underfunded,鈥� she said. 鈥淲e don’t need to be wasting our local Knox County taxpayer money on somebody’s agenda that is not intended to promote the education safety and wellness of our public school students.鈥� 

鈥楾he clear constitutional boundary鈥�

Another school that could spark a lawsuit over public funds for religious schools is Colorado鈥檚 , which advertises that it offers students a 鈥淐hristian foundation.鈥� 

The school operates 鈥減retty much just like a charter school鈥� said Ken Witt, executive director of Education reEnvisioned, the board of cooperative educational services, or BOCES, that contracted with the school. 

As , emails between the attorney for the Pueblo County district, which allowed the school to open within its boundaries, and the Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative law firm, suggest the school was intentionally founded to test the legal argument over whether public schools can practice religion. 

After threatening to withhold state funds because of the school鈥檚 religious mission, the Colorado Department of Education funded Riverstone鈥檚 31 students. But the state is also conducting a , which could take another year, before deciding whether it can legally provide money to the school. In the meantime, Riverstone had to close its building last week because of health and safety violations. It鈥檚 unclear whether students are learning remotely or in another facility in the meantime.

For now, Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser, a Democrat running for governor, hasn鈥檛 issued an opinion on Riverstone, but his views on St. Isidore, the Oklahoma school, were clear. Last year, he in opposing state funding for the school.

In , he urged the Supreme Court 鈥渢o preserve the clear constitutional boundary that protects both religious liberty and the integrity of our public education system.鈥�

Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, a Republican who is also running for governor, made a similar argument about St. Isidore before both the Oklahoma and U.S. supreme courts. 

But that鈥檚 where both he and Weiser split with the Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti. In his , Skrmetti states that categorically excluding faith-based schools from public charter programs violates parents鈥� rights to freely exercise their religion.

To Ilya Shapiro, director of constitutional studies at the conservative Manhattan Institute, it鈥檚 a matter of equity. Higher-income families can move into wealthier neighborhoods or pay private school tuition, he wrote in a on the Wilberforce case. The state, he added, already funds religious schools through education savings accounts. 

鈥淏ut families who rely on charter schools are told that their options must be secular,鈥� he wrote. 

Black, with the University of South Carolina, said the issue comes down to who authorized the school to begin with. In both Oklahoma and Tennessee, either local or state boards approve charter applications.

鈥淭hat explicit state involvement, to me, makes it clear that state action is involved,鈥� he said, 鈥渁nd thus the Establishment Clause applies.鈥�

He began opening monthly board meetings with a Christian prayer, released a about protecting children from transgender students, and at odds with his agenda. The next two and a half years were marked by a steady stream of edicts, incendiary statements and disruptions that included , funding delays and conflicts with .

鈥淓very seven days you could expect something coming. It was almost like clockwork,鈥� said Robert Franklin, a former associate superintendent of Tulsa Tech, a district that offers career and technical education programs. 

As Walters leaves his post as state superintendent to head the Teacher Freedom Alliance, a national anti-union organization, Oklahomans say his turbulent administration offered a preview of the Trump administration鈥檚 鈥溾�� approach to overhauling education. Despite about educators 鈥渃losest to the child鈥� knowing what鈥檚 best in the classroom, Education Secretary Linda McMahon, like Walters, has embraced an aggressive, top-down approach that frequently targets teachers for an assortment of perceived ills, from equity policies to protecting the rights of LGBTQ students.

In February, an Oklahoma City called his state a 鈥渢esting ground for Project 2025,鈥� the conservative Heritage Foundation鈥檚 920-page strategy document that federal agencies are closely following. In the same way Walters welcomed like David Barton and Dennis Prager to influence a rewrite of the state鈥檚 social studies standards, the Trump administration has assembled dozens of conservative leaders and organizations to shape a for the nation鈥檚 250th birthday.

In both cases, improving schools took a backseat to a singular 鈥� some might say, relentless 鈥� focus on the culture war. Walters鈥� grip on the state鈥檚 schools was 鈥渁 microcosm of what we鈥檙e now facing at the federal level,鈥� said the Rev. Shannon Fleck, executive director of Faithful America, an online community that seeks to counteract Christian nationalism. 

In Oklahoma, where she led an interfaith network, educators grew fearful for their jobs as Walters teamed up with , who created , to monitor teachers鈥� social media. In Washington, McMahon laid off 1,300 staffers and officials told districts nationwide that they would lose federal funds if they didn鈥檛 eliminate programs aimed at closing racial achievement gaps. 

To some right-leaning groups, Walters was a champion for parental rights whose 鈥渃ourage鈥� deserves respect. 鈥淗e showed that it鈥檚 possible to push back against the machine,鈥� a supporter on Facebook. 

In part due to his use of to get himself on conservative media, Walters鈥� actions drew attention far outside his state. But the visibility also made him fodder for . Stephen Colbert called out the Oklahoma chief鈥檚 mandate that every classroom have a Bible and teachers incorporate scriptures into their lessons.

鈥淥ur kids have to understand the role the Bible played in influencing American history,鈥� Walters said in a video from behind his desk last year after spending on 500 Trump-endorsed Bibles for AP Government courses. 鈥淚t鈥檚 very clear that the radical left has driven the Bible out of the classroom. We will not stop until we鈥檝e brought the Bible back to every classroom in the state.鈥�

For Oklahoma superintendents, the mandate was no joke. 

鈥淢ost of my colleagues across the state are in the front row at their local church every Sunday, and here’s this guy forcing the Bible on them,鈥� said Craig McVay, who retired in 2022 as superintendent of the El Reno district, outside Oklahoma City, and is now for state superintendent. 

accused Walters of trying to local curriculum, noting that students were already allowed to bring their own Bibles to school. 鈥淓specially in the smaller communities of this state, it’s very difficult to stand up against Jesus, and that’s what he forced them to do.鈥�

He largely failed.

Most districts have no plans to change current practices, while both the and the blocked Walters鈥� plan to purchase 55,000 Bibles.

Trump hasn鈥檛 conditioned federal funds on Bible reading in public schools, but the federal department is expected to issue new guidance on what he called 鈥渢otal protection鈥� for . Some worry the administration will over other religions in violation of the First Amendment. 

鈥楾rumpier than Trump鈥�

After Trump鈥檚 November victory, Walters created a special committee to help the state comply with the president鈥檚 education agenda. In a letter to parents, he called Trump 鈥渁 fearless champion of efforts to eliminate the federal bureaucracy that has shut local communities and parents out of the decisions that impact their students鈥� educations.鈥� Some speculated that Walters, who did not return calls or texts to comment for this article, was for a job in Trump鈥檚 cabinet, particularly the one the president ultimately gave to McMahon. 

His frequent social media posts continue to voice unwavering support for Trump on issues such as , , and even .

Leslie Finger, an assistant professor of political science at the University of North Texas, said she wondered if Walters鈥� strategy toward achieving 鈥減olitical prominence鈥� was to be 鈥淭rumpier than Trump.鈥� 

She pointed, for example, to Kari Lake, the former TV news anchor and Trump ally who that former President Joe Biden won Arizona in 2020. She sued, unsuccessfully, to overturn a gubernatorial election she lost to Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs in 2022 and still denies she lost her in 2024.

But while Trump chose Lake to lead, and , the U.S. Agency for Global Media, which runs Voice of America, Walters never got the nod. To Derek Black, a constitutional law professor at the University of South Carolina, that鈥檚 surprising.

鈥淗is brazenness seems to be a character trait the administration values, which begs the question of why he stayed in Oklahoma,鈥� Black said. It鈥檚 鈥渟omewhat likely,鈥� he added, that Walters 鈥渓acked the insider network to get a position high enough to suit him.鈥�

Once Trump was re-elected, Walters advanced policies that seemed to stay one step ahead of his hero. He pushed through that expect students to 鈥渋dentify discrepancies in 2020 elections results,鈥� even though ruled there was no evidence that the Biden campaign 鈥渟tole鈥� the election. , the standards present the 鈥渇ull and true context of our nation鈥檚 founding and of the principles that made and continue to make America great and exceptional.鈥� The Oklahoma Supreme Court the state from implementing them after parents, teachers and faith leaders sued, arguing the standards require teaching from the Bible. 

Over 1,300 miles away, the Trump administration is undergoing a similar overhaul of the Smithsonian museums in Washington, D.C., to replace 鈥渋deological indoctrination or divisive narratives that distort our shared history.” Exhibits, , focus too much on 鈥渉ow bad slavery was鈥� and offer 鈥渘othing about Success, nothing about Brightness, nothing about the Future.”

In line with Trump鈥檚 immigration policy, Walters to round up undocumented students at school and instructed districts to collect parents鈥� citizenship status when they enrolled their children. The state legislature opposed the plan.

The federal government has attempted to bar undocumented children from attending Head Start and issued that prohibits students, including those in high school, from receiving tuition assistance for career and technical education.

鈥楥hristian patriot鈥�

To Black, the law professor, Walters was 鈥渟o far out of bounds鈥� that he 鈥渃ared even less about rules 鈥han the current administration.鈥�

He required teachers from New York and California, seeking to work in Oklahoma, to take a to screen out 鈥渨oke鈥� applicants 鈥� a move said would discourage efforts to recruit teachers. But as with Trump, his boundary pushing endeared him to Christian nationalists, who maintain a strong foothold in Oklahoma. One group, the Tulsa-based City Elders, considers Walters a 鈥淐hristian patriot鈥� who worked to advance their mission of 鈥渆stablishing the kingdom of God鈥� on earth and infusing government with Christian principles.  

鈥淭his is a war for the souls of our kids,鈥� Walters in 2022. 鈥淭he brilliance of our founders and the acknowledgement of almighty God 鈥� that’s where our blessings come from. That’s where our rights came from 鈥� and the left wants us to take that out of schools.鈥�

Last August, when GOP lawmakers called for investigations into Walters鈥� management of state education funds, members of the group school board meetings and were the first to sign up to speak. 

City Elders hosted him again at a gala in March, but , organized by groups that oppose Christian nationalism, gathered outside the Tulsa-area conference center. Some waved signs that said 鈥淚mpeach Walters,鈥� calling him a 鈥渄anger鈥� to education.

A month later, he came face-to-face with critics during a 鈥渢own hall鈥� event organized by the Turning Point USA chapter at Oklahoma State University, considered one of the colleges in the country. Co-founder Charlie Kirk, who was assassinated Sept 10 in Utah, founded the organization to mobilize college students around conservative ideas and encourage open debate.

But Walters couldn鈥檛 finish his sentences amid the angry chants about his and his following the death of a nonbinary student last year. He called Nex Benedict鈥檚 death, later determined to be a suicide, a tragedy. But he also used the moment to voice opposition to schools that allowed students to use facilities that don鈥檛 align with their sex assigned at birth. His administration, he said, would not 鈥渓ie to students鈥� about being able to change their gender. 

At the time, he was still a potential candidate for governor. In June, suggested that while Walters trailed frontrunner Attorney General Gentner Drummond by 27 percentage points, a path to the Republican nomination wasn鈥檛 impossible. Some question why a politician with Walters鈥� ambition would walk away for a new position with an uncertain future. He was also eligible to run again for state superintendent.

鈥淚t’s pretty rare for someone to resign [during] their first term in a position when they’ve got another one available,鈥� , a civics and voting rights advocate, said on a 罢丑耻谤蝉诲补测.听

While Walters and were once close, observers say the superintendent had no chance of getting the . They had a series of on issues ranging from Walters鈥� attempt to take over the Tulsa schools to his support for immigration raids at school. Walters鈥� allegiance to Trump may have worked against him, said Jeffrey Henig, a professor emeritus of education and political science at Teachers College, Columbia University. 

鈥淭here’s an odd lack of symmetry in the politics around Trump,鈥� he said. 鈥淐rossing him is close to political suicide for Republicans, but trying to read from his script does not confer equal and proportionate success.鈥�  

When McMahon visited the state in August, she a charter school tour with the governor鈥檚 office, not Walters 鈥� a move widely viewed as a political snub. 

In a farewell letter to parents, he counted eliminating 鈥渨oke indoctrination鈥� and teacher recruitment efforts among his accomplishments. He that 151 special education teachers, including 34 from out of state, would receive signing bonuses of $20,000. It was Kirk鈥檚 death, he r, that inspired him to take the job at the Teacher Freedom Alliance and that 鈥渘ational leaders鈥� recruited him for the position.

鈥淲e have to have more people step up on the national stage to protect this country’s values,鈥� he said. 鈥淲e’ve got to get rid of the teachers unions.鈥� 

In typical outsized fashion, Walters didn鈥檛 just pay his respects to Kirk. He mandated that schools hold a moment of silence on Sept. 16 at noon 鈥� at a time when students would be eating lunch or enjoying recess. 

He followed up with a declaration that all Oklahoma high schools would open a Turning Point USA club, even though leaves those decisions up to local school boards.

To Franklin, who took opposite sides with Walters on issues like Christian charter schools, the moment was telling. The former Tulsa Tech official said it underscored why Walters, despite the backing of right-wing groups like the Heritage Foundation and Moms for Liberty, might struggle outside of聽Oklahoma.

As Walters assumes a new national position, Franklin said that unlike Kirk, the former chief never sparked a 鈥済roundswell of 鈥極h my God, we need to listen to this guy,鈥� 鈥� Kirk鈥檚 organization had over 900 college chapters prior to his death and has since to establish thousands more. His campus appearances could draw thousands.

鈥淭he Charlie Kirk phenomenon only strikes every once in a while, and I don’t think Walters has that kind of following.鈥�

Now Christian schools in Maine, where the case originated, want the courts to go even further. 

They object to a state law that requires them to accept all students, including those who don鈥檛 follow their religion, have disabilities or identify as LGBTQ. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit heard the case in January.

鈥淭his moral panic over letting religious schools be religious 鈥� even if they鈥檙e receiving tuition subsidies 鈥� needs to end,鈥� said Adele Keim, senior counsel with the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty. The nonprofit law firm represents St. Dominic Academy in Auburn, Maine, which sued over the rule along with CrossPoint Church, which operates . 

The nondiscrimination law, schools say, prevents them from participating in 鈥渢own tuitioning鈥� 鈥� a program that picks up a student鈥檚 private school costs if there鈥檚 no public option in their community. 

The state argues that it鈥檚 only asking religious schools to comply with the same rules public and secular private schools follow.

鈥淭he schools are asking for special treatment,鈥� said Alexandra Zaretsky, litigation counsel for Americans United for Separation of Church and State. The nonprofit advocacy group submitted a brief to the court in support of Maine鈥檚 position. 鈥淚t should be the state鈥檚 prerogative to say 鈥業f you’re getting funding from the state, then you have to follow our generally applicable laws.鈥� 鈥�

Most states with voucher programs already allow private and religious schools to deny admissions to whomever they want. Maine is an outlier 鈥� a blue state that would prefer to keep religious schools out of the tuitioning program. 

The debate reflects a heightened concern among advocates for public education that the nationwide push for private school choice will further isolate students.

鈥淩eligious schools getting the taxpayer-funded ability to pick their own kids is one real goal of this school voucher push 鈥� a feature, not a bug,鈥� said Joshua Cowen, an education professor at Michigan State University. Last year, he released a book that delves into the way culture war battles have fueled private school choice.

In March, in opposition to Texas鈥� new ESA law, which passed in April with help from President Donald Trump. The president of the state House, urging them to vote yes. Earlier in that , which lasted nearly 24 hours, Laura Colangelo, executive director of the Texas Private School Association, said private schools could deny admission to a child whose mother wasn鈥檛 married when she got pregnant.

says the state can鈥檛 force a school to modify policies tied to their religious beliefs. If the Maine case goes the religious schools鈥� way, such rules would be 鈥渓ess necessary,鈥� Cowen said.

鈥淚鈥檓 a Christian man. I sing in a church choir. I can still say what these schools want to do is wrong,鈥� he said. 鈥淭hese guys just want a blank check to do what they want, even if it鈥檚 leaving some kids and families out.鈥�

A 鈥榮ource of balkanization鈥�

The issue was also at the forefront of Oklahoma鈥檚 legal fight to open a religious charter school, a debate that both supporters and opponents of the idea expect to eventually wind up back in court.

In April, the U.S. Supreme Court tied 4-4 on the question of whether charter schools are private and can explicitly teach religion. The deadlock allowed the Oklahoma Supreme Court鈥檚 decision against St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School to stand. Though promising not to turn any students away, school leaders said they would only call students by their birth names and pronouns and would refer students with disabilities to their local district if accommodating their needs disrupted class.

Some experts see the prospect of sectarian charter schools as a threat to American values. 

鈥淧ublic education, including public charter schools, is one of the few things that holds our society together,鈥� said Richard Kahlenberg, who directs the American Identity Project at the Progressive Policy Institute, a think tank. 鈥淚t’s the common experience for 90% of American schoolchildren.鈥� 

鈥淚f you suddenly have 鈥� Christian students going to their schools, Jewish students going to theirs, Muslim students going to theirs, that means fewer Christian students come to know Jewish and Muslim students as classmates and friends,鈥� Kahlenberg said in a panel discussion prior to the Supreme Court鈥檚 ruling in the Oklahoma case. 鈥淥ur public schools are already highly segregated by race and class, and this would just layer on religion as a new source of balkanization.鈥� 

鈥業nfinite number of options鈥�

In Utah, the state鈥檚 teachers union sued last year over a new ESA program because they say it 鈥渄iverts鈥� education funds to schools that discriminate in admissions. In April, a state district court judge ruled the program unconstitutional.

鈥淲e firmly believe, and a judge agreed, that public money belongs in public schools,鈥� said Hailey Higgins, communications director for the Utah Education Association.

To choice supporters 鈥� and the Trump administration 鈥� the more private schools that cater to families鈥� individual preferences, the better. That鈥檚 the argument that the Institute for Justice, a libertarian law firm, along with parents currently in the program, made in to the Utah Supreme Court.

When she learned about the lawsuit, Amanda Koldewyn, an Ogden mother of four, said she felt 鈥渁nger, frustration and panic.鈥� Her 12-year-old son, who has autism, was getting sick from anxiety in public school and was 鈥渂ored out of his mind鈥� in class. The Utah Fits All scholarship allowed her to find a curriculum where he can move at his own pace and pay a private math tutor for her daughter. She hopes to use the program for her 5-year-old twins this fall as well.

鈥淚 can actually get the resources that aren’t just passable, but are fine tuned to what my children need,鈥� she said. 鈥淚 get really, really angry at those few teachers who think public school is the only way.鈥�

The debate over whether religious schools in choice programs can refuse to serve families who don鈥檛 share their values is also playing out with younger students in Colorado. The state鈥檚 universal preschool program requires participating schools to accept students from families regardless of parents鈥� housing status, income level, or religion, sexual orientation or gender identity. 

Two over the regulation, saying they couldn鈥檛 participate in the program because their faith prohibits them from accepting LGBTQ students or parents. That means the state doesn鈥檛 pick up the cost for students in those schools. The case is now before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit. 

In other countries, it鈥檚 far more common for students to attend religious schools at the government鈥檚 expense. , fully funds Catholic school districts. In European countries like the Netherlands, attend government-funded religious schools.

Many countries place on those schools that choice advocates in the U.S. would resist, explains Sam Abrams, director of the International Partnership for the Study of Educational Privatization at the University of Colorado, Boulder. Religious schools often follow the same criteria for student admissions as public schools, teach to national standards and submit to monitoring visits.

鈥淚t鈥檚 all regulated, and you can鈥檛 screen kids out,鈥� he said, noting that in recent school choice cases, the conservative justices on the Supreme Court never referenced how these systems work in other countries. 鈥淭hey’re not going to talk about the European system. It forces them to acknowledge that what [the U.S.] is doing is very different.鈥�

Maine鈥檚 demands on religious schools depart from the way the tuitioning program used to operate. For decades, Catholic and other religious schools were 鈥渨illing and active participants in this program,鈥� Keim said. That ended in the 1980s 鈥� what she called the 鈥渟hag carpet-era view of the Establishment Clause鈥� 鈥� when the legislature passed a law excluding religious schools.

鈥淔or 25 years, Maine families have been knocking at the courthouse door and asking the federal courts to let them back in,鈥� Keim said. 

In 2021, as the Carson case made its way to the Supreme Court, lawmakers amended the to prohibit discrimination against students in all private schools receiving public funds, including religious schools. The real 鈥減oison pill,鈥� she said, is a provision that requires religious expression without discrimination. 

鈥淚f they鈥檙e going to allow a Catholic pro-life club,鈥� she said, 鈥渢hey鈥檙e going to have to allow a Catholic pro-choice club.鈥�

If the schools prevail in court, St. Dominic鈥檚 won鈥檛 be accepting any high school students. While the pre-K through eighth grade school will still operate, the this year due to low enrollment. 

鈥淚鈥檓 sure the picture would be different,鈥� Keim said, 鈥渋f they had been allowed to receive these subsidies over the long term.鈥�

He praised a new breed of 鈥減atriot pastors鈥� who are mobilizing the faithful to engage in 鈥渂iblical citizenship鈥� by voting and getting involved on school boards. He鈥檚 among the far right religious who say former President Donald Trump is God鈥檚 choice for president and that Christians should not only participate in government and politics, but .

Republican leaders have spent a lot of energy this year putting those words into action. Much of the spotlight has been on Oklahoma state Superintendent Ryan Walters, who mandated that schools stock classrooms with Bibles. Louisiana passed a law requiring schools to post the 10 Commandments in classrooms, the subject of , while the Texas Education Agency has proposed a reading curriculum that includes stories from the Old and New testaments. 

But the question of whether those ideas will resonate with Christian voters on Nov. 5 is harder to answer.

One suggests they might not. On a long list of concerns influencing Christians this election, public schools ranked near the bottom, with less than 30% choosing it as a reason to vote for a presidential candidate. The economy and border security topped the list for at least 60% of voters. 

A lot of churchgoers are 鈥渟till leery of bringing Christianity overtly into public institutions,鈥� said George Barna, who runs the Cultural Research Center at Arizona Christian University, a small conservative college outside Phoenix. 鈥淭hey are more likely to desire the freedom to believe and practice their faith of choice, with their family, as they desire, without government intrusion.鈥�

His recent poll suggests that many practicing Christians are so disillusioned by both Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump that they may not even vote. Barna estimated that as many as 104 million 鈥減eople of faith鈥� 鈥� and of those, roughly 32 million regular churchgoers 鈥� won鈥檛 show up at the polls. 

Trump tried to shore up his support among the faithful this week during a with conservative pastors, suggesting a failed assassination attempt against him in July was a sign. 鈥淕od saved me for a purpose,鈥� he said. Conservative leaders are counting on Christians to support their preferred candidates 鈥� up and down the ballot. 

Walters co-authored an earlier this year with Steve Deace, a conservative talk show host, and David Barton, whose organization teaches history from a Christian perspective. In grave terms, they urged Christians to vote for Trump if they want schools to embrace their values.

鈥淐hurches and community groups must transform into centers of evangelical activism, educating and equipping members to take a stand in this cultural and spiritual battle,鈥� they wrote. 鈥淭he election ahead is more than a political contest; it is our opportunity to affirm our commitment to our nation鈥檚 Judeo-Christian values.鈥�

But that message doesn鈥檛 always grab voters, said Kendal Sachierri, a conservative Republican running for state Senate in Oklahoma and a former Spanish teacher. A Second Amendment advocate, she defeated an incumbent who to increase penalties for having a gun on school property. 

When she was going door-to-door during the primary, Sachierri said she talked to voters who were unhappy with public schools.

鈥淏ut no one was like, 鈥榃e need Bibles in the classroom,鈥� 鈥� she said. When she taught at聽Newcastle High School, south of Oklahoma City, she had both English and Spanish versions of the Bible available for students. 鈥淒id I ever make a kid use it? No.鈥�

鈥楤iblical foundation鈥�

In local races this year, there have been signs that the public鈥檚 support for candidates who align with fundamentalist Christian groups is waning. School board hopefuls backed by Moms for Liberty haven鈥檛 fared nearly as well in primary races as they did two years ago when they earned school board seats across the country. 

The organization primarily advocates against lessons on gender and sexuality, but their summit last year also featured Tim Barton, David Barton鈥檚 son and Wallbuilders president. He preached that depends on rebuilding its 鈥渂iblical foundation.鈥� 

Whether Christian voters have tired of such rhetoric enough to stay home on Election Day is hard to forecast, said Michael Emerson, a religion and public policy researcher at Rice University. 

鈥淎ttempting to estimate who will vote and who will not is unreliable,鈥� he said. 鈥淎s we have seen in the past, especially with Trump, people often say they are not voting, or not voting for him, to pollsters, but then go ahead and vote for him.鈥�

Christians, in fact, have an on elections, he said. 

That鈥檚 especially true in Texas, where frequently mix. In conservative communities, it鈥檚 almost expected that a candidate鈥檚 platform will include references to Christianity, said Calvin Jillison, a political scientist at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. 

鈥淚f you’re in a red district, you better be able to speak about these issues in a way that you know voters will respond,鈥� he said. 

The state鈥檚 official calls for schools to require instruction from the Bible, and wealthy conservative donors have thrown their support behind candidates who espouse a 鈥溾�� in public schools. 

They include state school board candidate Brandon Hall, a political newcomer who wants to emulate Walters鈥檚 effort in Oklahoma to purchase classroom Bibles.

鈥淭his is amazing. Let鈥檚 do it in Texas!鈥� he wrote on .

For Hall, who identified himself as a pastor in campaign documents but also works for a , promising to promote in schools was a winning strategy. He sailed past a 22-year incumbent in the March primary with over 53% of the vote in a Fort Worth-area district.

Since then, he鈥檚 been busy promoting the Texas Education Agency鈥檚 new K-5 reading curriculum that features Bible stories and emphasizes the evangelism of the nation鈥檚 founding. As 社区黑料 first reported in May, critics say it doesn鈥檛 reflect the religious diversity of Texas students and borders on proselytizing. (Wallnau has on X to ask state board members to vote for it next month.)

鈥淲hy do liberals hate the new curriculum so much? Second graders will learn courage through the story of Queen Esther,鈥� Hall in September after speaking to a community group about the program.

Hall didn鈥檛 respond to voicemails or messages on Facebook 鈥� and hasn鈥檛 participated in candidate interviews with .

鈥淢aybe he鈥檚 not concerned,鈥� considering the makeup of the board has shifted more in recent years, said Rayna Glaser, his Democratic opponent. 

But as she attends campaign events and house gatherings to meet voters, she鈥檚 hoping that Christians will consider what could happen if the public school curriculum becomes subsumed by theology. 

鈥淲e’ve got the Quran. We’ve got the Book of Mormon. Do you want Satan in there? Because I know you don’t want Satanism being taught in school,鈥� she said. 鈥淎s a Christian woman who believes in God and believes the Bible, I feel like if you open [schools] to one, you really have to open them to others.鈥�